‘Marshals’ Takes ‘Yellowstone’ Into New Territory And It Shows Promise [Review]

When Yellowstone, Taylor Sheridan’s defining New West drama, ended in December 2024, it left more than just a legacy. It left questions, top among them was what would become of the Dutton dynasty and the stories audiences had followed for five seasons. Answers arrived quickly. Paramount announced two new chapters in the expanding universe: The Dutton Ranch, centered on Kelly Reilly’s Beth and Cole Hauser’s Rip, and Marshals, which finds Luke Grimes returning as Kayce Dutton as he steps into life beyond the Yellowstone ranch. Given the immense popularity of Yellowstone, any spinoff is guaranteed an immediate audience. But built-in fanbases come with built-in expectations. Marshals carries both the weight of that legacy and the challenge of translating Kayce’s story into the procedural rhythm of a weekly law enforcement drama. Thanks to CBS, I was able to screen the first three episodes to see whether Marshals lives up to those expectations as the Yellowstone franchise heads into new territory

Kayce Is Again Looking For Purpose

When we last saw Kayce Dutton on Yellowstone, he had made a choice that reshaped his family’s future. The Ranch was sold to Thomas Rainwater and the Reservation, and Kayce moved his family to the East Camp property, determined to live as a rancher outside the long shadow of the family name. For the first time in years, he appeared at peace, focused not on obligation, but on building a future with his family.

Marshals finds Kayce still at East Camp, living the ranch life with his son Tate, but it doesn’t take long to see that peace is fragile. Kayce’s life has been defined as much by loss as loyalty. His mother died when he was young. His brother was killed, and his father was murdered. He and Monica endured the devastating loss of their unborn son. Tragedy has marked nearly every chapter of his life. Without diving into spoilers, Kayce once again finds himself navigating grief. Some fans may have hoped for a lasting happy ending, and this new turn may divide opinion.

Luke Grimes fully steps into the spotlight this time, and with the series centered on Kayce, he makes it count. Given more space to explore the character, Grimes balances Kayce’s tragic past with a man again searching for renewed purpose. The quiet intensity that defined him remains, but Marshals allows him to channel it into something proactive. Kayce is no longer defending land or legacy; he’s defending people. That shift gives Grimes room to evolve the character, delivering a performance that feels both familiar and newly driven.

Marshals Leans Into Kayce’s Warrior Past

During the 5 seasons of Yellowstone, we were reminded, sometimes subtly, sometimes explosively, that Kayce Dutton wasn’t just a ranch hand with a big last name. He was a former Navy SEAL. Those skills surfaced in bursts, but were often few and far between. On Yellowstone, that background was more subtext than centerpiece. Marshals change that.

Here, Kayce’s military past isn’t just a character detail; it is foundational to the series. The show leans into his tactical training, strategic mindset, and combat instincts as core tools of the job. When situations escalate, and they often do, the series doesn’t shy away from showcasing the kind of action that Kayce’s background naturally supports. One such situation in an early episode showcases coordinated tactical movement that you’d

For fans who always felt those glimpses of SEAL-level capability were underutilized, Marshals delivers in a big way. The action is more frequent, more deliberate, and more central to the storytelling. Gone is the ranch politics and simmering family drama, replaced with boots-on-the-ground law enforcement and high-risk situations. For viewers who gravitate toward more action-forward storytelling, that shift is likely to be one of the show’s biggest strengths.

Marshals‘ Procedural Format Works

If we’re being honest about Yellowstone, there were long stretches where Kayce Dutton existed on the periphery. He was a central figure in the early seasons, but as the series evolved, the focus shifted more heavily toward John, Beth, and Jamie. Kayce often found himself reacting to events rather than driving them. His storylines were frequently tied to family conflict and the tension in his marriage to Monica. Marshals doesn’t have that problem.

With Kayce positioned as the centerpiece, the series gives Luke Grimes consistent narrative weight. The procedural structure ensures he isn’t sidelined for episodes at a time. Each case places him at the heart of the action, forcing him to make decisions, take risks, and be an active part of the story. The tradeoff, of course, is the tone. This isn’t the slow-burn family saga that defined Yellowstone. The storytelling moves with greater urgency. Conflicts escalate faster. Episodes are built around missions and investigations rather than multi-episode land disputes or Dutton power struggles. However, within that framework, the show finds a rhythm.

During the first few episodes, this format mostly works. Some cases resolve a bit too neatly, and the supporting cast still feels in early-stage development, but those are common first-season growing pains rather than structural flaws. Also, the “bad guy of the week” format could feel formulaic for some, especially if you are expecting the layered drama of the original series. But the format keeps the pacing tight while still allowing character moments to surface organically. Just don’t expect to see Kayce brooding in wide-open Montana landscapes for extended stretches.

Kayce Has A New Team

No series is complete without a team of varied personalities and the dynamics they bring to the screen. Marshals is no exception. What’s perhaps slightly different than the usual here is that while Kayce is unquestionably the central character, he isn’t the team leader. That role belongs to Pete Calvin (Logan Marshall-Green), a former Navy SEAL who shares a past with Kayce. Marshall-Green brings a layered intensity to the role, balancing command presence with personal vulnerability. Beneath his leadership role, Calvin is quietly wrestling with emotional turmoil tied to his family, struggles he appears to be managing through pills. It’s a subtle but important thread that adds tension to his leadership and hints at deeper complications as the season progresses.

The rest of the team adds their own potential to the ensemble. Belle Skinner (Arielle Kebbel) carries signs of a troubled family past she’s clearly trying to outrun, setting up personal stakes that feel primed for exploration. Miles Kittle (Tatanka Means) has ties to the Black Rock Reservation, creating built-in tension as he navigates the space between his cultural roots and his federal law enforcement role. The final team members, Andrea Cruz (Ash Santos), a transplant from the Bronx, provides an outsider’s perspective and doesn’t seem entirely sold on life in Big Sky country or the advances from cowboys at the local bar.

Across the first three episodes, each team member is given room to establish their personality and purpose within the unit. While Kayce remains the focal point, as expected for a spinoff built around a fan-favorite character, the foundation is clearly being laid for the supporting cast to evolve. As the show settles into its rhythm, the team dynamic feels poised to deliver compelling storylines beyond Kayce’s own journey.

Marshals Balances The New With The Familiar

A spinoff series always carries the challenge of attracting new viewers while still rewarding the fans who have been there since the beginning. For longtime fans of Yellowstone, the series includes a handful of subtle nods to the larger universe. References to past events, including the infamous “Train Station”, serve as quiet acknowledgments of the world Kayce comes from. They’re not overplayed or treated as required viewing, but serve as touchpoints for those who have followed the franchise from the beginning.

The series also brings back familiar faces like Thomas Rainwater and Mo, providing continuity and reminding viewers that this story still exists within the same Montana landscape. Their presence helps ground the show in established relationships and history without overtaking the new direction the series is carving out.

At the same time, Marshals makes a concerted effort to stand on its own. New viewers jumping in without five seasons of Yellowstone history won’t feel lost or overwhelmed. The show doesn’t rely on deep-cut lore to move the story along, and there is plenty of exposition from other characters to fill in the needed gaps about the legacy of the Dutton family. However, some of the more subtle references may not carry the same weight for newcomers. A line of dialogue about “keeping family skeletons in the closet” or a knowing look will resonate more deeply with established fans who understand the history behind it. But none of it is essential to following the weekly story.

Final Thoughts

Marshals is clearly positioned as a Western version of CBS’s long-running hit SEAL Team. That makes complete sense given that executive producer Spencer Hudnut is steering the ship. And that comparison isn’t a knock at all, but simply a necessary level-set. This is not the slow-burn family saga that defined much of Yellowstone, nor is it trying to be.

The procedural format exists for a reason. CBS shows like SEAL Team and NCIS have endured for years because audiences respond to that blend of weekly stakes, character-driven arcs, and contained storytelling. When done properly, the format offers consistency, momentum, and room for characters to grow over time. That’s where Marshals finds its promise. It may not deliver the tense family drama that preceded it, but it does offer something that feels accessible.

Fans expecting Yellowstone 2.0 may need to adjust their expectations. Marshals may not carry the operatic weight of the previous Dutton saga, but they understand their mission. Give Kayce purpose, momentum, and a battlefield of his own. For fans willing to embrace a new format, this next chapter feels less like a replacement and more like an evolution.

Marshals Trailer

WE WANT TO HEAR FROM YOU

Sound off and tell us what you think. Are you looking forward to the Marshals? Also, were you a fan of Yellowstone?

You can share your thoughts with us by leaving a comment below or on our That Hashtag Show Facebook page. You can also find me online @TheIndianaSlone. And be sure to stay up to date on your Entertainment and Pop Culture News by following us at ThatHashtagShow.com.

KEEP READING:

‘The Madison’ Michelle Pfeiffer Deals With Tragedy And Grief In Official Trailer