This week has been one hectic week for Subnautica 2. First came the legal ruling that put Ted Gill: the founder of Unknown Worlds Entertainment, back in control of his company. All while the judge castigated Krafton for their illegal actions, including illegally firing the founders in the first place, to boot. Then just a day later, Krafton officially announced via a leak of an internal memo and then confirmation of that memo that Subnautica 2 will finally release into Steam Early Access sometime in May 2026. All this should’ve been the end of this whole debacle, right? Well, as it turns out…

Game File has just reported that Krafton leaked the release window for Subnautica 2 without the approval of Ted Gill: newly reinstated CEO of Unknown Worlds. Even the lawyers representing Gill and the other co-founders of Unknown Worlds were “surprised” by the release window announcement from Krafton. In response, said lawyers have just sent a letter to the judge presiding over the case, Vice Chancellor Lori W. Will of Delaware’s Court of Chancery, asking her to find Krafton in contempt of court for violating the judge’s orders not to interfere with Subnautica 2‘s development and release. The lawyers asserted in the letter:

Krafton self-servingly announced the launch without any regard to its impact on the game, the team, or the community—let alone this Court’s Opinion. Announcing the release of a game is momentous, and it is typically accompanied by significant marketing activity, fanfare, and community coordination. And most importantly, the announcement is carefully designed to maximize excitement for the game. That entire process was supposed to be driven by Mr. Gill. However, in defiance of the Court’s Opinion, Krafton has now taken that away, further damaging the game and sowing additional confusion among the Subnautica community.

The Unknown Worlds lawyers further speculate that Krafton “had intentionally” leaked the internal memo and then officially confirmed it to various news outlets, including IGN and PC Gamer. Moreover, those confirmations came after the Unknown Worlds lawyers had written their letter to the judge, and sent copies to Krafton’s legal counsel.

Subnautica 2 Release Window Leak Effectively Sabotages Game Release

Furthermore, the lawyers argue that by leaking a release window for Subnautica 2, Krafton is effectively locking Unknown Worlds into a release window of Krafton’s own choosing, and denying Ted Gill any opportunity to review the game before launch. Especially since the game had been developed for nine months under Steve Papoutsis: a CEO with no experience with either Subnautica or Early Access releases…and who made that decision about the game’s launch window at at time when he was no longer CEO of Unknown Worlds. Their statement reads:

While Gill is supremely confident in the skill and dedication of Unknown Worlds’ development team, they have been working for months at the direction of management that, as the Court recognized, had no prior experience with the Subnautica franchise or early access.

…

Moreover, Gill must deal with publishing agreements, launch advertising planning, and other back-end issues. He now needs to do so with the axe of fan disappointment hanging over his head if he changes the launch timing.

As a result of this Unknown Worlds’ lawyers are asking the judge to force Krafton to explain why they shouldn’t be sanctioned for this, stating:

Krafton’s actions have undermined the relief sought in this expedited phase of the litigation, in which the Founders spent nine months and millions of dollars fighting to restore their bargained-for right to determine when and how the game would launch.

Krafton Response a Complete Mess

Krafton’s responses to all of these accusations have been…shaky, to say the least. First, in response to the accusation that they improperly leaked Subnautica 2‘s release window without Gill’s approval:

Papoutsis’s message was simply celebrating the UW employees’ efforts toward a past event: Krafton’s pre-Opinion determination that Subnautica 2 was ready for Early Access release. There was nothing improper about conveying the results of the milestone review or thanking the development team for their dedication and talent.

In his role as CEO, Gill will be able to assess independently his views on the state of Subnautica 2 and the appropriate release schedule; nothing in Papoutsis’s message alters Gill’s authority or discretion.

Moreover, in a separate filing, Krafton’s lawyers are also trying to dispute the timing of the legal ruling itself. They are trying to insist that the ruling doesn’t actually take effect until an “implementing order” is signed, effectively nullifying the idea that Papoutsis was not the acting CEO at the time Krafton leaked the memo.

Krafton Leak of Subnautica 2 Release Window Throws Game’s Future into Question

Even after the legal ruling, they want to sabotage Subnautica 2 so badly that they are willing to risk legal consequences for it. And remember: this is all just to keep Unknown Worlds from getting a $250 million payout. Well, who knows how much Krafton has to pay in legal fees now. And this is not even counting an increasingly likely contempt charge due to Krafton basically trying to act like trolls towards the judge by basically arguing “Oh, we were so happy that we couldn’t help but leak the release window. Oopsies, sorry, but not sorry.”.

Even worse, this entire debacle throws the future of Subnautica 2 into question. Even Krafton just trying to sabotage the game’s release via a low profile release window announcement devoid of the usual marketing and fanfare is problematic on its own. However, the fact that Krafton are trying to force the release window so early after Ted Gill’s reinstatement raises some serious questions about the game itself. Did Krafton make radical changes to the game in the nine months they had full control of it via Papoutsis? Are they trying to prevent Gill from reverting those changes via this release window leak by not giving him enough time to review the game prior to launch? Unfortunately, all of this is pure speculation until we get more information at a later date.

All we know for certain is that Subnautica 2‘s May 2026 release window is now no longer certain.

What do you all think? Are you now also worried about the future of Subnautica 2? Are you eagerly awaiting what sort of punishment Krafton will get for blatantly violating a court ruling? Tell us your Alterra-like thoughts in the comment section below.

Source: Game File

Keep Reading:

Netflix’s Assassin’s Creed Series Begins Filming In Rome, Plus New Cast